If you're comparing LiveGood and AG1, you're essentially asking one question: is $79/month for a greens powder actually worth it when a competing product costs $9.95? That's a $69/month gap — $828 per year. The answer matters.
We did a full head-to-head across price, ingredients, certifications, and the membership model so you can make an informed decision — not one driven by AG1's massive marketing budget.
Bottom line up front: AG1 has a broader ingredient list and stronger brand recognition. LiveGood Super Greens costs 87% less per month and delivers the core active ingredients at clinical doses. For most people, LiveGood wins on value — decisively.
Price: The Biggest Gap in the Supplement Industry
Let's start with the number that makes this comparison so stark:
| Product | Monthly Cost | Annual Cost | Per Serving |
|---|---|---|---|
| AG1 (Athletic Greens) | $79/mo (subscription) | $948/yr | ~$2.63 |
| LiveGood Super Greens (member price) | $9.95/mo | $119.40/yr + $9.95 membership | ~$0.33 |
| LiveGood membership fee | $9.95/mo | $119.40/yr | — |
| Annual savings vs AG1 | ~$709/year saved by switching to LiveGood | ||
AG1's price includes a sleek pouch, an aggressive influencer marketing program, and one of the highest customer acquisition costs in the supplement industry. You're paying for the brand as much as the product.
LiveGood's membership model strips all of that out. No middlemen, no retail markup, no influencer commissions baked into product cost. The savings are structural — not because the ingredients are inferior.
Ingredients: What's Actually Inside
This is where the comparison gets nuanced. AG1 has a longer ingredient list — 75 vitamins, minerals, and whole-food ingredients. LiveGood Super Greens is more focused, hitting the highest-impact greens and functional mushrooms at clinical doses.
Get the Free Supplement Savings Guide
See exactly how much you could save on supplements each month — with real member vs retail price breakdowns.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
AG1 Ingredient Highlights
- 75 total ingredients across vitamins, minerals, probiotics, adaptogens, and greens
- Proprietary blends (exact amounts not always disclosed)
- Ashwagandha, rhodiola, reishi, spirulina, chlorella
- Digestive enzymes and probiotics (7.2 billion CFUs)
- NSF Certified for Sport (important for competitive athletes)
LiveGood Super Greens Highlights
- Organic greens blend: spirulina, wheatgrass, barley grass, chlorella, alfalfa
- 6-mushroom complex: lion's mane, reishi, chaga, turkey tail, maitake, shiitake — all at disclosed doses
- Full label transparency — no proprietary blends
- Third-party tested for purity and potency
- No artificial colors, flavors, or fillers
| Category | AG1 | LiveGood Super Greens | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Number of ingredients | 75+ | ~20 (focused) | AG1 (breadth) |
| Label transparency | Partial (prop. blends) | Full disclosure | LiveGood |
| Mushroom complex | Some (reishi, etc.) | 6-mushroom complex | LiveGood |
| Probiotics | Yes (7.2B CFUs) | No | AG1 |
| Organic greens | Yes | Yes | Tie |
| Third-party tested | NSF Certified for Sport | Third-party tested | AG1 (more rigorous cert) |
AG1's NSF Certified for Sport certification is genuinely valuable — it tests for banned substances, making it the choice for competitive athletes subject to drug testing. For the other 99% of people, third-party testing for purity and potency covers the bases.
The proprietary blend issue cuts both ways: AG1's long ingredient list looks impressive, but when individual ingredient doses aren't disclosed, it's difficult to know whether you're getting clinical doses or label decoration. LiveGood's transparency is a real advantage for anyone who wants to know exactly what they're taking.
Certifications & Quality Standards
| Standard | AG1 | LiveGood |
|---|---|---|
| NSF Certified for Sport | ✓ Yes | No |
| GMP Compliant Manufacturing | ✓ Yes | ✓ Yes |
| Third-party tested | ✓ Yes | ✓ Yes |
| No proprietary blends | No (some blends) | ✓ Yes (fully transparent) |
| Dairy-free | ✓ Yes | ✓ Yes |
| Gluten-free | ✓ Yes | ✓ Yes |
The Membership Model Difference
AG1 is a direct subscription: $79/month, one product. You can cancel, but you're locked into that price point for that single product.
LiveGood is a platform: $9.95/month unlocks wholesale pricing on 30+ products. If you buy Super Greens plus a multivitamin plus magnesium, each at member prices, you're still paying a fraction of what you'd spend on comparable products at retail.
- AG1: $79/mo for 1 product
- LiveGood: $9.95/mo membership + product prices averaging $8–18 each → complete stack for $50–60/mo total
The math isn't close once you consider a full supplement regimen. See our supplement membership vs retail guide for a deeper breakdown of how the model works.
Who Should Choose AG1?
AG1 Makes Sense If You:
- Are a competitive athlete subject to drug testing (NSF certified)
- Want the broadest single-product coverage (75 ingredients)
- Prioritize convenience over cost
- Don't want to manage a membership
- Value the brand credibility for social signaling
AG1 Is a Poor Choice If You:
- Care about cost (87% cheaper alternative exists)
- Want full ingredient transparency
- Need to budget — $948/yr is a lot for greens powder
- Want to cover multiple supplement needs affordably
- Don't want to support influencer-driven pricing
Who Should Choose LiveGood?
LiveGood Makes Sense If You:
- Want to save $709+/year on greens alone
- Take multiple supplements and want a wholesale platform
- Value label transparency and full ingredient disclosure
- Want the 6-mushroom complex at clinical doses
- Are health-conscious but budget-aware
LiveGood Is Not Ideal If You:
- Are a competitive athlete needing NSF Sport certification
- Don't want any membership commitment
- Only want one product and don't want a platform
Our Verdict
LiveGood wins on value — AG1 wins on certification prestige
For the vast majority of health-conscious adults, LiveGood is the better choice. The ingredient transparency is better, the mushroom complex is superior, and saving $709/year is not a trivial benefit. You can use those savings to add a full supplement stack — multivitamin, magnesium, D3/K2 — and still spend less than AG1 alone.
AG1 earns its place for competitive athletes who specifically need NSF Certified for Sport status. Outside that use case, you're largely paying for marketing.
If you're currently paying $79/month for AG1 and you're not a tested athlete, switching to LiveGood could save you over $700 this year.
Try LiveGood Super Greens for $9.95/month
$49.95 one-time enrollment + $9.95/month. 60-day money-back guarantee. Cancel anytime.
Get StartedThis article contains affiliate links. If you join LiveGood through our link, we earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products we've researched and believe in.